Don’t need a strata inspection report?
Most new strata-title properties have defects - Sydney Morning Herald May 21, 2012
The most comprehensive study ever of strata properties has found 85 per cent of new apartments in
NSW are plagued by defects. The results of the two-year, federally-funded University of NSW study reveal
major problems with compliance and management of multi-unit dwellings, which accounted for 75 per
cent of properties built in Sydney in the five years to 2009.
Researchers surveyed 1550 strata owners, managers and peak bodies. Seven out of 10 owners reported
building defects in their properties, with water leaks and internal and external cracks the most common.
Newer apartments were the worst, with 85 per cent of owners surveyed in buildings constructed since
2000 reporting defects. In three out of four cases, these were yet to be fixed. In most of these cases, the
builder or developer controlled the strata scheme and was slow to act, or the builder was no longer
operating and so could not fix the defects.
The president of Owners Corporation Network Australia, Stephen Goddard, said the City Futures
Research Centre study confirmed the conventional wisdom of the strata sector: new buildings in NSW
will have defects. ''We do not live in a safe state, if that is the outcome,'' he said. ''Why have a building
code if we can't comply with it 85 per cent of the time?''
Changes to planning regulation before the Sydney Olympics permitted private certification of buildings in
a bid to speed up development times.
The report's lead author and research fellow at the centre, Hazel Easthope, said certification was ''not up
to scratch'' between 1998 and 2004. Regulation was tightened in 2005. ''Compliance was not very good,''
she said. ''You hear stories of buildings being signed off without inspectors even going to the building.''
But Mr Goddard said the continuing state of compliance ''makes your blood run cold''. ''We have an
absolutely inadequate process for certifying work, no adequate penalties for punishing falsified
certifications,'' he said.
About 3 million Australians now live in strata-titled properties, including 1.2 million in NSW, where the
form of home ownership was first introduced in 1961. Almost a quarter of people living in the Sydney
metropolitan area live under strata title.
The report found parking, noisy neighbours and breaking by-laws were the biggest source of disputes.
Managing schemes proved problematic for 39 per cent of strata owners, with the necessity of repairs and
who should pay for them common sources of conflict.
Mr Goddard said the focus needed to shift from aiding developers constructing flats to helping people
come to terms with living co-operatively within them. ''People do not understand strata title and its
consequences,'' he said. ''They are told they have a certificate of title but they discover you can't do with
it as they wish.''
Dr Easthope said strata was a new form of civic relationship, where owners found themselves in a legally
binding relationship with their neighbours for the communal upkeep and maintenance of their property.
''Owners corporations are … like a small level of government but with very little support.''
The Governing the Compact City report, to be launched today by the Fair Trading Minister, Anthony
Roberts, comes as the government undertakes its own review of strata law.